It is common to observe that Asians are the “new Jews” — academic over-achieving victims of quotas, now dressed up as “diversity”-based affirmative action. In a striking variation on that theme, the author of the comment I’m about to quote argues that it is American whites who are the new Jews and, interestingly, that liberal American Jews are allied with the new discriminators.
These remarks were submitted as a Comment to my post immediately below, The Most Explosive Content Of Obama’s Mideast Speech, but I promoted them to post level to raise their visibility and to see if anyone cared to comment.
So the Israeli Jews are perturbed by the notion that their country could be carved out from beneath them and handed to an exploding population of hostile aliens who already have their own wretched homelands? And this destruction would occur under the most transparently phony universalist rhetoric.
What a coincidence, so are Whites perturbed in our lands.
And so facing such similar perils, what do American and European Jews say to Whites who are struggling against our own impending dispossession? Why they say “Nazi!” of course.
So with equal measure of friendship in heart, I have some advice for Israeli Jews that comes from an unimpeachable source: American Jews. That advice is to renounce their hate. The world has no place for such bigotry and Jewish supremacism. Israel is going to become an Arab nation. Don’t fight change, embrace it. Israel is a land of immigrants and the hordes of ululating muslims are just that: hard working immigrants looking to make a better life for themselves. How heartless of the Jews to deny them this opportunity to live in Israel by the tens of millions. The Jews should celebrate diversity; perhaps establish a national holiday honoring Arafat.
Hopefully the Israeli Jews will follow these prescriptions so as to cultivate the same prosperous, safe, and peaceful utopia that has resulted from the preferred policies of American Jews.
the author of the comment I’m about to quote argues that it is American whites who are the new Jews
With respect, my point was not that Whites are the new Jews. It was that Jews are—in a best case scenario—staggering hypocrites. In the worst case, they are engaged in ancient tribal warfare against Whites. Either way, it would take an act of willful disregard beyond my capacity to not take note of their “poison for thee, but not for me” offer to Whites.
Though If I were to pursue the theme that Whites are the new Jews, my conclusion would be the opposite: Whites are the new anti-Jews. Were it otherwise, we could reasonably expect Whites to do the following:
● Guard the border of their nations, while simultaneously influencing other countries (Israel for instance) to open theirs to countless millions of hostile parasitic aliens. Whites would explain to the colonized peoples that to resist this encroachment would be “racist.”
● Form explicit White interest and agitation groups in other countries (Israel for instance), and vigorously attack any media or entertainment content that reflects poorly upon them (in America this would offer full time employment for thousands simply to police the anti-White, anti-Christian bilge issuing forth from Hollywood).
● Openly consider what is in their best interest when discussing policy positions. Also to openly track White progress and strategize on how to improve White position, power, and population worldwide. And they would do this proudly.
● Elect leaders who explicitly vow loyalty to Whites and their interests. Imagine—if you are able—a White President making the following statements:
“We are flooded with a surge of refugees who threaten to wash away our achievements and damage our existence as a White democratic state.”
“ (immigrants) are causing socio-economic and cultural damage and threaten to take us back down to the level of the Third World.”
http://www.jta.org/news/article/2010/01/21/1010257/netanyahu-illegal-immigration-threat-to-israel
● Finally, alluding back to my earlier comment, Whites would ceaselessly chastise (formerly) cohesive and largely homogenous populations as full of “hate” and “supremacy.” Those populations (the Jews in Israel for instance) who attempted to resist this inversion of their traditional culture and dispossession of their traditional peoples would be told simply to accept their demise—no, embrace it! Embrace multiculturalism and diversity (concepts which would have no place whatsoever in the “new Jew” White countries of course).
I should note that I don’t mention these contradictions to impugn Jews. On the contrary, I think Whites should adopt every one of their plainly successful tactics. And while I have a high degree of sympathy toward the plight of Jews in Israel, it is leavened daily by what I perceive as their hostility toward my people in America.
According to some demographers, Jews constitute a moderately declining 76% of Israel. According to every demographer, and anyone’s functioning eyes, Whites constitute a rapidly declining 63% of America. I would like to see both trends arrested and reversed. And I’m certain that nearly all Jews would agree–on one count.
My problem with the attack on hypocritical Jews is not that no Jews are hypocritical. Many are, and for the reasons pointed out in this commenters two comments. But insofar as they are hypocritical (or the ones that are hypocritical) are so because they are liberal Jews, not because they are Jews. Most Jews, of course, are liberal, and vote Democratic, but not all. I am even more bothered by the use of “Whites” as a foil. To the degree that we are being threatened by the forces and people that that threaten us, it is American society and values being threatened, not “Whites.” America and white are not synonyms.
But insofar as they are hypocritical (or the ones that are hypocritical) are so because they are liberal Jews, not because they are Jews.
So liberal Jews, that is to say 80% of all Jews, are hypocrites on existential national questions and should be dismissed as wormtongues when they speak on the issue. So what of the few remaining? If the handful of conservative Jews are to be less hypocritical than their more numerous fellows, then they would have to embrace either A) nationalism for Jews in Israel and nationalism for Whites in their homelands, or B) A multicult polyglot society in both. So which of A or B is the position of conservative Jews? I’m asking honestly.
My understanding of conservative Likud-leaning Jews is that they are highly nativist and favor a strong jewish super-majority in Israel. If I am wrong on this, I’ll gladly retract. Though if this is their position, do these conservative Jews also favor a strong White super majority in Europe and America? If so, their support has been so subtle as to be imperceptible.
In fact, many conservative Jews have written phrases like “America and white are not synonyms.” Alright, fine. Then neither are Israel and jew. And so what on Earth is conservative Jew Netanyahu yammering on about with his hate, supremacy and intolerance filled tirades about immigrants damaging Israel’s existence as a jewish state? What “jewish” state?
I am even more bothered by the use of “Whites” as a foil.
And what of this bothers you? You put Whites in quotes as if they are a figment of imagination and not real people with real culture and real concerns. Are “Jews” the only legitimate people? Do you write things such as “Blacks” “Hispanics” or “Asians?” I think all of these disparate peoples exist and thus have no need for quotation marks. And they certainly think they exist. But maybe there are just Jews and then a huge indistinguishable mass of others.
it is American society and values being threatened, not “Whites.”
Whites are not being threatened? Well that certainly is a relief. I thought I noticed every White nation on Earth being invaded by hostile aliens. And I thought I noticed White women being raped by the thousands and the public fisc being gouged to pay for those who despise us. I also thought I noticed that as our nations become less White, they also become poorer, more violent, and less cohesive. This sounds mildly threatening to me. I wonder if the trajectory of American Whites will continue down from the 90% I was born into to its current 63%, to 43% to 23% to 13% to 3%. And I wonder at what juncture commenters like yourself will notice the semblance of a threat. I also wonder if you would be so sanguine about Israel if the “Jews” fell to minority status–would you perceive that threat? Though I suppose as an extinct race Whites won’t be threatened any longer!
And finally what is this American society of which you speak? Are there some bonds of culture, blood, kinship, or creed which tie together the millions of wildly incompatible people currently occupying this geography? What are the shared values? What is the proposition and who pray tell is abiding by it?
I object to the concern about race here. The issue should be values.
“Of 40 Intel [Science Talent Search ] finalists — the brightest science students in the U.S. — 16 have parents born in China, 10 in India, one in South Korea and one in Iran”. All decent people — including White ones — benefit from these immigrants. Our goal should be to try to get the RIGHT immigrants.
http://www.joannejacobs.com/2011/05/top-young-scientists-are-immigrants-kids/
Porter writes:
“According to some demographers, Jews constitute a moderately declining 76% of Israel. According to every demographer, and anyone’s functioning eyes, Whites constitute a rapidly declining 63% of America. I would like to see both trends arrested and reversed.”
and…
“Whites are not being threatened? Well that certainly is a relief. I thought I noticed every White nation on Earth being invaded by hostile aliens.”
Well, things sure don’t change much on Discriminations over the years, do they? I will tip my hat to John for at least appearing somewhat uncomfortable with the White Separatist campaign lobbied by Porter, but as I told you and all of your readers years ago…what kind of folks did you THINK were going to march with you on this anti-preferences parade? If most of your sermons consist of “Blacks got something that Whites deserved” how can you be surprised that aggressive-Aryan-ascendancy-agitators are shouting amen from the pews?
Porter writes:
““And finally what is this American society of which you speak? Are there some bonds of culture, blood, kinship, or creed which tie together the millions of wildly incompatible people currently occupying this geography? What are the shared values? What is the proposition and who pray tell is abiding by it?”
I’m an African-American who can trace his ancestors back to slavery. There’s between 17% and 25% European DNA in me (speaking of mass rape) as a result of said slavery. We live in a nation where Barack Obama and Dick Cheney are cousins.
“Bonds of Culture?” What on earth are you talking about? Go to your local mall and watch teenagers wearing over-sized denim shorts text each other while waiting on-line to see “Transformers 3”, (that’s after you dodge the skateboarders on the sidewalk). We’re a country with Black Country Singers, White Rappers, Hispanic Governors and Asian Violinists who just watched and cheered for the melting-pot Dallas Mavericks win the NBA title. We order bagels for breakfast and General Tso’s chicken on the weekend.
Again….what on earth are you talking about?
–Cobra
I have read similar sentiments on white supremacist/nationalist/whatever websites. This is one instance where they are correct. Prime Minister Netanyahu has ordered additional fencing on the border with Egypt and strict enforcement of laws prohibiting employment of illegal immigrants. He has even singled out illegal aliens from Sudan and Chad as lowering the cultural and economic capital of Israeli society. Netanyahu is forthright about wanting to maintain the Jewish character of Israel. But note this is not a racial criterion — fully half of Israeli Jews are themselves refugees and their descendants from Arab countries and physicially often indistinguishable from their Arab Muslim counterparts.
The white supremacists point out that while the ADL and AJC support an open border with Mexico and essentially unlimited immigration into the U.S. (even of anti-Semitic Muslims?) , the same organizations have been hypocritically silent on Israel’s openly nationalist and nativist immigration policy.
I disagree however that a whites-only immigration policy for the U.S. is the answer. The real issue as LTEC points out is making sure immigrants are actually a net benefit to the U.S. and not a burden. Furthermore, we need to make sure that new immigrants do not bring their own bigotry and prejudices with them. If an immigrant resents whites because he associates them with British colonialism for example, he should leave this resentment at home or stay home. Demanding preferences from the government and private sector because one has a Spanish last name is just as odious as preferences of yesteryear based on possession of a good English name.